KikiTheCat wrote:a room in a house is much much easier (though not cheaper) to make into an acoustically acceptable environment, and there are several approaches to doing so.
The shape of the room will play a factor, but that's taken into account when building a listening room. overall a good listening room in a house is always going to be far more sonically accurate than any car's interior unless you distort the conditions to prove some deluded point :)
Yes if you live in an apartment in the inner city you're not going to have an ideal listening room, but most people who can afford speakers and amplifiers worthy of a dedicated listening room are going to own their own house anyway and can afford to design a room around those speakers if that's their passion, much the way we modify our cars around the audio systems because we go beyond the average Joe, too.
If you want to see some insane interconnects and some voodoo descriptions of sonic superiority, check out a company called Kharma:
http://www.kharma.com/
If you have the $ to build your own listening room, you have the $ to completely redo your car for SQ.
You could make it 100% dead... redo the entire interior to be a certain shape if need be...
Or move the seat to the middle if you really want to get fun with it.
"unless you distort the conditions to prove some deluded point"
Which you just did with HT... how many people actually have enough money to dedicate and entire *listening room* in their house? Out of those... how many have the $ to throw down to dedicate that room when they are building the house?
Both have major issues and both have workarounds... but saying a house is inherantly better than a car ignores all of the problems with a normal HT setup. What if you have a big opening on either side of the room into the other rooms.. that would be like having to always keep your windows down in a car... how is that better?
If you say you can do this and that to make a great listening room, you can say the same thing for a car... it can be easily "fixed" to provide a superb listening environment.. whether or not you are willing to hack your dash/move your seats is no different than whether you are willing to tear down a wall in your house and move it 2 feet so that you can have better acoustics.
Buying a car specifically for SQ is also no different than buying a room in your house specifically for HT.
And btw... who says whether or not equipement is "worthy" of a listening room? You could just as easily make a listening room for a boom box or a 100k master HT setup... the only thing that matters is that you HAVE a listening room. Does that also mean you can't put a 100k master HT setup in your existing living room that is 10x10 archway into the kitchen because the acoustics just arent good enough?
Or maybe you can't have kicks in your car because you run coaxials? Perhaps you should *only* be allowed to mount component sets in kicks... doors are illegal.
I'm not going to apologize for having an opinion - if you view my disagreement as flaming something is very wrong here!