by Jonathan » Mon Jul 25, 2005 7:14 pm
Only time I don't use OD is when I know that the car would be constantly changing back and forth from Drive to overdrive, or OD would be at so low of an RPM that it would be stressing the transmission due to torque converter stall and heat buildup (assuming the converter doesn't lock until a certain speed). In town, putting it in drive will save gas due to fewer shifts and also help the transmission last longer since the tranny isn't constantly shifting back and forth, which heats up the transmission since the gears are constantly changing, and in many cases, the torque converter stalling since the RPM is so low. New cars are designed to have a mushy shift because people percieve that a soft shift is easier on a transmission, but really the reverse is true. Everytime a transmission shifts, there is an overlap period in the shifts that forces the transmission to slip in between gears, which gives a softer, smoother shift, similar to if you rode a clutch really bad in a manual tranny. All the power in between the shifts transfer to the clutches and bands in the form of heat, causing them to weaken over time. It's also wasted power since you're burning gas during that slippage and not getting a lot out of it. That's the premise behind shift kits, they can improve the life of friction materials in a transmission by over double. That's why I try to keep a tranny shifting as little as possible. Of course, I started driving in the early 80s and during the 80s tHe first OD automatics had somewhat weak OD bands when they started, they've gotten much better over time. If I know I'm going to drive 45+ and will be on a steady cruise, I use OD as my normal gear, if I'm in town and the car would be shifting constantly, I just leave it in drive until I hit the highway then put it into OD.
Only time I don't use OD is when I know that the car would be constantly changing back and forth from Drive to overdrive, or OD would be at so low of an RPM that it would be stressing the transmission due to torque converter stall and heat buildup (assuming the converter doesn't lock until a certain speed). In town, putting it in drive will save gas due to fewer shifts and also help the transmission last longer since the tranny isn't constantly shifting back and forth, which heats up the transmission since the gears are constantly changing, and in many cases, the torque converter stalling since the RPM is so low. New cars are designed to have a mushy shift because people percieve that a soft shift is easier on a transmission, but really the reverse is true. Everytime a transmission shifts, there is an overlap period in the shifts that forces the transmission to slip in between gears, which gives a softer, smoother shift, similar to if you rode a clutch really bad in a manual tranny. All the power in between the shifts transfer to the clutches and bands in the form of heat, causing them to weaken over time. It's also wasted power since you're burning gas during that slippage and not getting a lot out of it. That's the premise behind shift kits, they can improve the life of friction materials in a transmission by over double. That's why I try to keep a tranny shifting as little as possible. Of course, I started driving in the early 80s and during the 80s tHe first OD automatics had somewhat weak OD bands when they started, they've gotten much better over time. If I know I'm going to drive 45+ and will be on a steady cruise, I use OD as my normal gear, if I'm in town and the car would be shifting constantly, I just leave it in drive until I hit the highway then put it into OD.